Time Is a Flat Circle: The Return of Impressions for Zero-Click Searches

Marketing professional discovers how to measure zero-click searches.

What goes around comes around. The hallmark of digital marketing is its ability to track clicks and aggregate data to inform future decision making. But with more zero-click searches happening every day, marketers are observing drops in performance data. As a result, awareness-based KPIs are back on the front burner.

By Jared Frank | 7 min read
Last Updated: June 13, 2025

I’ve been seeing a lot of blogs and YouTube videos pronouncing the death of SEO. Don’t fall for the clickbait. PPC might be dead, but marketers still need strong SEO, even if for slightly different reasons than recent times. Yes, zero-click searches are the new reality for SEO marketers. But that’s life. We must adapt.

SEO isn’t dead, it’s different. Specifically, it lives by different metrics. Google continues to be the largest traffic source and grow its pool of users. In March 2025, Google shared publicly that it now processes over five trillion search queries annually. This figure is more than double the number it last reported in 2016 and represents about 90% of global market share. So eyeballs remain on Google, but fingers are not always on touchpads.

Google as a marketing channel is as relevant as it’s ever been. But marketers are changing back to the OG of advertising metrics to measure success on the channel.

Key Takeaways

Click-through rate was the golden calf metric worshipped by digital marketers. Google is still the alter, but now, search impressions, not clicks, are the new holy grail.

Users source more answers now from Google’s zero-click products (e.g. AI Overviews and Knowledge Panels), both for convenience and because they consider those results pure and more authoritative.

Research suggests the average customer journey now contains 11.1 touchpoints. Because Google Search remains one of the most important discovery channels on that journey, marketers must still dominate SEO.

A Brief History of (Marketing) Time

As the old saying goes: “History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes.” Back in the prehistoric times before the internet when I think dinosaurs still roamed the earth, marketing largely consisted of billboard ads, print ads, TV ads, and radio ads. Marketing equaled advertising. The marketplace bought and sold advertising, and measured its success ahead of time, based entirely on the number of impressions the content owner/publisher (e.g. newspapers, TV shows, etc.) “guaranteed.”

Then the internet came along. And over the course of thirty years, this technological meteorite killed all the dinosaurs (newspapers, linear television, radio stations) who charged advertisers for “impressions” that may or may not ever happen.

Here is an example from the olden times. A newspaper’s total number of subscribers determined its advertising rate card. So an advertiser paid the publisher based on the number of copies distributed, not how many copies those subscribers actually read.

Fast forward to the dawn of the internet age, where a new term emerged – digital marketing. Soon digital marketing became just marketing, and business leaders referred to the old way of doing things as “traditional” marketing or “legacy” marketing. And if you curated those dusty relics, they weren’t very fun to talk about on first dates or at family reunions. So everyone updated their LinkedIn profiles and changed the way they made their living. And if you owned stock in Facebook and Google, you became a gazillionaire.

Clicks, Data, and Attribution

John Wanamaker, a titan of the retail industry in the 19th century, once famously said, “Half the money I spend on advertising is wasted. The trouble is I don’t know which half.”

What John Wanamaker needed was digital marketing. The digital sphere’s transaction is the click, its currency the data. This new system produced a new term for the marketing textbooks – attribution.

Attribution enables marketers to leverage data from clicks to know exactly what’s working and what’s not, double down on those profitable channels, and scale back on those channels returning small returns. Essentially, marketers now knew which half of their spend they wasted.

AI Is the New Technological Meteorite

Now fast forward again to today. Generative AI is changing the world in much the same way the internet did. OpenAI launched ChatGPT in November 2022, and in less than three months, it reached 100 million users – the fastest adoption rate in history by a country mile. Growth has accelerated further since then. Open AI CEO Sam Altman has hinted that the AI engine now boasts 800 million weekly active users. The speed of growth is astounding.

Gen AI is the modern-day gold rush. Thousands of companies have shoveled out tens of thousands of new products without an owner’s manual or full understanding of their capabilities. Because companies are shooting first and asking questions later, there have been a few unintended casualties.

SEO and Zero-Click Searches

According to Bain & Company, 80% of consumers now rely on zero-click results at least 40% of the time. AI has left SEO wounded along the side of the highway. PPC is roadkill.

SEO will survive and thrive again. The absolute number of searches is still increasing on Google, but the relative number of clicks is decreasing. BrightEdge reports Google searches up 49% year-over-year, but click-through rates (CTRs) down 30%.

CTR was the golden calf metric worshipped by digital marketers. Google is still the alter, but now, search impressions, not clicks, are the new holy grail. Time is a flat circle.

Through that lens, Google today is more like a prehistoric TV ad than the Google from five years ago. Will marketers ever be able to measure zero-click traffic and conversions on Search (as well as on Gemini and other LLMs) the way they measured those things on Google Search Console? Probably. Time is a flat circle. But today, it’s all about impressions.

AI-Powered Search and Zero-Click Searches

Google prioritizes user experience so use of its products goes up. Hence all the different products now providing instant answers to search queries. The AI Overview is top of mind for marketers, but Google’s search products are numerous at this point, and many of them are not AI products.

Google Zero-Click Search Products

AI Overview
Direct Answer
Featured Snippet
Knowledge Panel
Google Business Profile
Map Pack (still a must-do for local SEO)

Landing atop the first page of Google’s rankings no longer lands you atop the search medal podium. Savvy marketers now want to show up in these zero-click products because that’s where users are increasingly sourcing their answers.

And these impressions are high-value impressions. If your company shows up in a Knowledge Panel for example, users view that search result as pure and more authoritative, leading them to trust your brand even more. So there is great value in the impression, even without the click. If you’re not in those zero-click search products, your competitors will be, and they’ll gain that brand awareness, while you will not.

The old guard may still crave the click, but it’s easier (and necessary) to swim with the zero-click current.

The Future of SEO and Zero-Click Searches

Google has committed to $75 billion in capex in 2025, most of that spend earmarked to support AI infrastructure. Their capital allocation reflects the increase of Google Search and user satisfaction measured since launching their AI-powered search products.

On a recent earnings call, Google CEO Sundar Pichai said, “We are seeing an increase in search usage among people who use the new AI Overviews as well as increased user satisfaction with the results.”

Zero-click searches are no flash in the pan. They are the new normal in response to market demand in the AI world. As marketers, we must respond with strategies to appear atop Google’s new search products in addition to SERP rankings.

Research from NP Digital suggests the average customer journey now contains 11.1 touchpoints, up from 8.5 touchpoints just four years ago. With Google Search now buttressed with an AI-powered experience, organic search will remain a common discovery channel on that journey. SEO still matters. With or without the click. Seat 36 Tiger Eye Logo

Do you need help with SEO writing for your business? Let’s chat.
Write to Jared at jared@seat36.com.

RELATED CONTENT